Three Times Hou Hsiao Hsien !new! -
In the 1911 segment, the choice of a silent film format strips away spoken dialogue to highlight the rigid social prison of the era. The heavy silence emphasizes the courtesan's inability to speak for her own destiny.
If you ask a cinephile to name the single most defining characteristic of Taiwanese master Hou Hsiao-hsien’s work, they will likely give you one answer: stillness . But in his 2005 masterpiece, Three Times (最好的時光), Hou redefined that stillness. He turned it into a kaleidoscope. The film is a triptych—three separate love stories set in three distinct eras of 20th-century Taiwan, each starring the same two actors (Shu Qi and Chang Chen) playing different lovers.
What makes Three Times so remarkable is its sheer stylistic range. It is arguably Hou's most accessible and varied film, offering something for both the uninitiated viewer and the dedicated cinephile.
'A Summer's Snow' (1983), Hou's seventh feature, marks a turning point in his career. This deceptively simple tale of a young girl's journey through a snow-covered landscape explores themes of isolation and disconnection. Shot in stunning monochrome, the film mesmerizes with its tranquil pace and attention to detail. three times hou hsiao hsien
The first segment, "A Time for Love," unfolds in the bustling pool halls of 1960s Taiwan. It evokes the nostalgia of youth and the fleeting nature of romantic connections.
In the 2000s, Hou shifted his focus to China, producing a series of films that explored the country's complex history and cultural heritage. Films like "Ang Lee's, er... Ah-Gong's" (2000) and "Three Times" (2005) showcase Hou's ability to craft compelling narratives that transcend cultural and linguistic boundaries. This period in Hou's career is marked by a more introspective and lyrical approach, often incorporating elements of Chinese opera and traditional storytelling.
In conclusion, Hou Hsiao-hsien's "Three Times" is a masterpiece of contemporary cinema, a testament to the director's innovative storytelling, cinematic craftsmanship, and profound understanding of the human condition. Through this trilogy, Hou invites us to reflect on the complexities of love, memory, and the passage of time, offering a rich and immersive cinematic experience that lingers long after the credits roll. In the 1911 segment, the choice of a
Set in the coastal city of Kaohsiung, this segment is widely considered the film’s most lyrical and evocative chapter. The Complexity of Minimalism: Hou Hsiao-hsien's Three Times
The film tracks how we communicate—from handwritten letters (1966) to silent intertitles (1911) and finally to impersonal SMS/emails (2005).
The trilogy explores the lives of three women, each representing a different era and societal context. Through their stories, Hou examines themes of love, loss, and the human condition. The episodes are characterized by a sense of melancholy and longing, reflecting the director's preoccupation with the ephemeral nature of life and human connections. For example, in "The Time That Remains," Hou portrays a poignant love story between two intellectuals in 1940s Japan, highlighting the tensions between personal desire and societal expectations. But in his 2005 masterpiece, Three Times (最好的時光),
Three Times has a unique origin story. It was originally conceived as an omnibus film, with Hou set to direct only one of the segments. However, the producers were unable to secure the financing to hire three separate directors, so Hou took over the production of all three. This happy accident resulted in a film that functions as a "summation of his career to date". Each segment directly echoes one of his previous major works, creating a profound dialogue between the director's own past and his present concerns. As critic James Udden notes, Hou's films are characterized by "sudden, unexpected, and often irreversible changes," a theme that provides the very "structural basis for Three Times ".
The second segment shifts back to 1911, during the Japanese colonial occupation of Taiwan. Set entirely within a Dadaocheng brothel, it depicts the relationship between a courtesan seeking her freedom and a political radical dedicated to the anti-colonial cause.
★★★★½ (minus half a star only because your neck will hurt from leaning toward the screen, trying to catch a whispered line that was never meant to be caught.)